Comments for KalaAfghana http://www.kalaafghana.com/site Bipran Ki Reet Tohn Sach Da Marg Tue, 07 Sep 2010 10:51:16 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.2 Comment on Letter From Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti to Gurbaksh Singh by Parminder Singh Johal http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=5#comment-3030 Parminder Singh Johal Wed, 08 Apr 2009 05:24:53 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=5#comment-3030 Waheguru Ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fathe I am currentley living in Ireland and i would like to know about the books that are been wrote by Shri. Kala Afgana Sahib, how will i be able to buy them ....... I hope you will do needful for me. Thanks. Regards Parminder Singh Johal Waheguru Ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fathe

I am currentley living in Ireland and i would like to know about the books that are been wrote by Shri. Kala Afgana Sahib, how will i be able to buy them …….
I hope you will do needful for me.
Thanks.

Regards
Parminder Singh Johal

]]> Comment on Brahmanical Practices at Golden Temple by sundeep singh http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=7#comment-2496 sundeep singh Wed, 28 Jan 2009 16:25:10 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=7#comment-2496 Mr Afghana when i was about 21 I was a fanatic supporter of Bindrewallia and the Khalistan movement, without doubt I accepted the the Akal Takts word as true and i believed all the stories associated with the Gurus i.e Guru Nanak ji moving THE Kabba at mecca with his feet and Guru Gobind Singh ji hunting rabbits etc to do avtaar but really it did'nt make sence to me because a lot of the stories contradicted Guru Nanak ji's teachings. I never really questioned these stories because i did'nt want to offend any of the Guru's so I just kept doing paat and prayed to God to enlighten me with some wisdom. Nothing really bothered me for a few years because i was content in family life and I was happy praying everyday and believing in the Guru Granth Sahib, but due to my misfortune one day browsing on the net about sikhism i stumbled accross the dasam Granth, i knew it excisted befor but in my youth i never read it because I was too busy being radicalised into a fundamentalist but this time arround i decided to study the granth. Brothers and sisters what i read in the dasam granth rocked my world, some of the stuff said in there is shocking regarding sex, idol worship, the contradictions to the guru granth sahib, i was disgusted in horror and amazement that guru ji could write such writtings. Still i did'nt want to question the authenticity because i did'nt want to offend my religion but God and common sence prevailed and i started to search for answers. The next step was to see what the akal takht had to say about the dasam granth and to my amazement they sanctioned it as authentic. The next step i took was to see if there was anyone else like me who questioned the authenticity of the dasam Granth and thank God there were people who had the same questions, this in itself gave me confidence to search for the truth. On my quest for the truth I wanted to see what bindrwallia thought of the dasam granth and i when i saw a video of him supporting it i realised what a fool i had been in my youth for supporting him, because the simplest of minds would realise after reading the dasam granth it is fraud and an attemtpt to destabalise the sikh panth and the worse thing is most of the sikhs are falling for it and the saddest thing is the Golden temple and the gianis associated with the akal takt are preaching brahman myths and stories which contradict the teachings of the Guru Granth sahib. I realised bachittar nattar natak was a lie and it was an attempt to inaugurate Guru ji and the sikh panth into brahman myths and basically a lot of the dasam granth tells of guru ji hunting for no reason and basically i realised all the doubts i had about sikhism were all due largely to the dasam granth.I need guidence about my religion and all im finding is lies i need truth and the sadeest thing is im finding truth on peace tv which is an islamic tv station, there you have docters and intelligent beings explaining religion, all we have is in fighting and a bunch of thick ppl doin pachaar. We need teachers and Gur Sikh docters and scientists explaining sikhism, all we have is uneducated ppl with minimum intellect explaing mythical stories. Mr Afghana when i was about 21 I was a fanatic supporter of Bindrewallia and the Khalistan movement, without doubt I accepted the the Akal Takts word as true and i believed all the stories associated with the Gurus i.e Guru Nanak ji moving THE Kabba at mecca with his feet and Guru Gobind Singh ji hunting rabbits etc to do avtaar but really it did’nt make sence to me because a lot of the stories contradicted Guru Nanak ji’s teachings. I never really questioned these stories because i did’nt want to offend any of the Guru’s so I just kept doing paat and prayed to God to enlighten me with some wisdom.
Nothing really bothered me for a few years because i was content in family life and I was happy praying everyday and believing in the Guru Granth Sahib, but due to my misfortune one day browsing on the net about sikhism i stumbled accross the dasam Granth, i knew it excisted befor but in my youth i never read it because I was too busy being radicalised into a fundamentalist but this time arround i decided to study the granth. Brothers and sisters what i read in the dasam granth rocked my world, some of the stuff said in there is shocking regarding sex, idol worship, the contradictions to the guru granth sahib, i was disgusted in horror and amazement that guru ji could write such writtings. Still i did’nt want to question the authenticity because i did’nt want to offend my religion but God and common sence prevailed and i started to search for answers. The next step was to see what the akal takht had to say about the dasam granth and to my amazement they sanctioned it as authentic. The next step i took was to see if there was anyone else like me who questioned the authenticity of the dasam Granth and thank God there were people who had the same questions, this in itself gave me confidence to search for the truth.
On my quest for the truth I wanted to see what bindrwallia thought of the dasam granth and i when i saw a video of him supporting it i realised what a fool i had been in my youth for supporting him, because the simplest of minds would realise after reading the dasam granth it is fraud and an attemtpt to destabalise the sikh panth and the worse thing is most of the sikhs are falling for it and the saddest thing is the Golden temple and the gianis associated with the akal takt are preaching brahman myths and stories which contradict the teachings of the Guru Granth sahib.
I realised bachittar nattar natak was a lie and it was an attempt to inaugurate Guru ji and the sikh panth into brahman myths and basically a lot of the dasam granth tells of guru ji hunting for no reason and basically i realised all the doubts i had about sikhism were all due largely to the dasam granth.I need guidence about my religion and all im finding is lies i need truth and the sadeest thing is im finding truth on peace tv which is an islamic tv station, there you have docters and intelligent beings explaining religion, all we have is in fighting and a bunch of thick ppl doin pachaar. We need teachers and Gur Sikh docters and scientists explaining sikhism, all we have is uneducated ppl with minimum intellect explaing mythical stories.

]]> Comment on Letter From Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti to Gurbaksh Singh by amrinder singh hundal http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=5#comment-2423 amrinder singh hundal Sat, 10 Jan 2009 09:48:24 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=5#comment-2423 sorry text space mukk gyi c.please clarify my above mentioned point.and who said that guru gobind singh ji revived panj piaras after killing them.guru pyaryo eh time aapas ch larhan da nhi,balki ikathe ho ke kesri chhat thalle rehan da hai.n please tell me whats wrong in making a memorial at the name of shaheed baba deep singh.if some fools lower their heads there,then this doesnt mean that its a place for idol worship.please do clarifx.waitin. sorry text space mukk gyi c.please clarify my above mentioned point.and who said that guru gobind singh ji revived panj piaras after killing them.guru pyaryo eh time aapas ch larhan da nhi,balki ikathe ho ke kesri chhat thalle rehan da hai.n please tell me whats wrong in making a memorial at the name of shaheed baba deep singh.if some fools lower their heads there,then this doesnt mean that its a place for idol worship.please do clarifx.waitin.

]]> Comment on Letter From Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti to Gurbaksh Singh by amrinder singh hundal http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=5#comment-2422 amrinder singh hundal Sat, 10 Jan 2009 09:42:26 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=5#comment-2422 waheguru ji ka khalsa,waheguru ji ki fateh das benti karda hai k gurbax singh ji di hakk sach layi larhan di ki philosophy hai.eh kehnde ne k jarnail singh bhindranwale paapi hai.ki hakk-sach layi larhna paap hai.if some so called jathedars are wrong,then it doesnot mean that amritdharis are wrong.there is a lot of difference.these jathedars are baptised so that they can loot money,bt look at the qurbanis of our puratan amritdhari souls waheguru ji ka khalsa,waheguru ji ki fateh
das benti karda hai k gurbax singh ji di hakk sach layi larhan di ki philosophy hai.eh kehnde ne k jarnail singh bhindranwale paapi hai.ki hakk-sach layi larhna paap hai.if some so called jathedars are wrong,then it doesnot mean that amritdharis are wrong.there is a lot of difference.these jathedars are baptised so that they can loot money,bt look at the qurbanis of our puratan amritdhari souls

]]> Comment on Bipran Ki Reet Toh Saach Daa Maragh by Harvinder Singh http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=10#comment-2345 Harvinder Singh Wed, 31 Dec 2008 11:51:03 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=10#comment-2345 Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ke Fateh, I started reading S. Gurbax Singh ji's books recently and I used to read his articles in Spokesman Magazine. I really appreciate his courage to stand-out and research the real sikh philosophy as engineered and detailed by Ten Guru Sahibans. All his books and articles are eye-opener including all his letters, which shows a True Path a Sikh should follow. I am trying to convince as many people as possible to read his books, starting from my own family, which is deeply engaged in Brahmanical practices as now I can understand after start reading his books. I think real respect to his great effort and research is to make all his books / articles available in every corner of the world and in every house. I wish all the very best for S. Gurbax Singh ji. I don’t have words to thank-him for his research. I hope he will be able to enlighten other souls with real meanings of Gurbani and Gursikhi for the centuries to come. May Nanak nirankari bless him with my life also. Regards, Harvinder Singh Waheguru ji ka Khalsa,
Waheguru ji ke Fateh,

I started reading S. Gurbax Singh ji’s books recently and I used to read his articles in Spokesman Magazine. I really appreciate his courage to stand-out and research the real sikh philosophy as engineered and detailed by Ten Guru Sahibans. All his books and articles are eye-opener including all his letters, which shows a True Path a Sikh should follow.

I am trying to convince as many people as possible to read his books, starting from my own family, which is deeply engaged in Brahmanical practices as now I can understand after start reading his books. I think real respect to his great effort and research is to make all his books / articles available in every corner of the world and in every house.

I wish all the very best for S. Gurbax Singh ji. I don’t have words to thank-him for his research. I hope he will be able to enlighten other souls with real meanings of Gurbani and Gursikhi for the centuries to come.

May Nanak nirankari bless him with my life also.

Regards,
Harvinder Singh

]]> Comment on Bipran Ki Reet Toh Saach Daa Maragh by major singh http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=10#comment-2011 major singh Mon, 17 Nov 2008 15:44:51 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=10#comment-2011 <p>THESE BOOKS ARE VERY NICE AND I REALLY APRICIATED</p> THESE BOOKS ARE VERY NICE AND I REALLY APRICIATED

]]> Comment on Bipran Ki Reet Toh Saach Daa Maragh by Makhan Singh http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=10#comment-1941 Makhan Singh Mon, 10 Nov 2008 21:51:32 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=10#comment-1941 I have read all his books many many times and have found something new eyeopener everytime. I bought first edition of every book when I was in India. Ihave not found the 9th vol . yet I can not get it from India. Is there a site from where I can download it. I recommend these books to every sikh who is stunch beliver of 10 Gurus and Guru granth Sahib ji. and keep distance from these khalistanis and taksalees and akhand kertaneey the so called fundamentalists, Who are out to destroy sikhi of Guru Nanak Ji. I have read all his books many many times and have found something new eyeopener everytime. I bought first edition of every book when I was in India. Ihave not found the 9th vol . yet I can not get it from India. Is there a site from where I can download it. I recommend these books to every sikh who is stunch beliver of 10 Gurus and Guru granth Sahib ji. and keep distance from these khalistanis and taksalees and akhand kertaneey the so called fundamentalists, Who are out to destroy sikhi of Guru Nanak Ji.

]]> Comment on Letters To Prof. Darshan Singh by balkar singh http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=4#comment-1931 balkar singh Fri, 07 Nov 2008 18:59:56 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=4#comment-1931 <p>Hi! very amused by the website .</p> Hi! very amused by the website .

]]> Comment on Maas Maas Kar Murakh Jhagare by gora lal http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=8#comment-1928 gora lal Thu, 06 Nov 2008 21:19:01 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=8#comment-1928 <p>Hello, I'm a regular visitor to your site so i finally decided its time to sign your guestbook, so here i sign !</p> Hello, I’m a regular visitor to your site so i finally decided its time to sign your guestbook, so here i sign !

]]> Comment on Brahmanical Practices at Golden Temple by hans http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=7#comment-1922 hans Wed, 05 Nov 2008 16:00:49 +0000 http://www.kalaafghana.com/site/?p=7#comment-1922 <p>It's a great website of yours. I surfed by and found it very informative. Bookmarked and check you back in a while</p> It’s a great website of yours. I surfed by and found it very informative. Bookmarked and check you back in a while

]]>